Skip to main content

Freebies and CJI N V Ramana

By Mohan Guruswamy

CJI N V Ramana on Thursday acknowledged that the impact of freebies promised by political parties on the country’s fiscal health was “a serious issue” but said he was not in favour of derecognising any party over it because that would be “anti-democratic”.

I think the CJI is on loose ground here. What is a freebie? Is education a freebie? In these days of distance learning is a laptop a freebie? Is giving farmers free power a freebie? Is subsidised rice or wheat a freebie? 

There are merited subsidies and unmerited subsidies. Economists classify them this way because free  or subsidised healthcare and education contributes to the national good in economic and social terms.

But giving a retired president or prime minister a paid for existence in a government house is certainly a freebie and the most unmerited of subsidies. Is 100% MSP procurement of paddy and wheat in Punjab a merited subsidy when it is denied to other states? Is subsidised milk or foodstuffs fine for urban people, when rural people don’t get such benefits?

We can even classify unmerited expenditures and merited expenditures. An ambulance ferrying passengers from remote areas to well equipped hospitals is a merited expenditure. But having two lavishly appointed giant jets together costing almost ₹9000 crores, and sitting idol most of the time a merited expenditure? 
 
I think we can have a meaningful discussion to list merited and unmerited expenditures. But the system may not like it. What we might want to consider is to cap the subsidies to a certain level of the GDP or budget. We can’t have subsidies eating away at capital expenditures for the common good. But we can cap capital expenditures for vanity projects like  a new secretariat or PM house. 

Is the writing off of about ₹10L Crs of corporate debt to PSU banks merited or an interested write off? Is having millions of cases piled up in the court system because the judicial system is under provided for in public interest? Sir please give a thought to this. Is it merited or unmerited.  

Think about it Mr.CJI. You are treading on a subject that few are willing to discuss and even fewer might be willing to implement!

Source: https://www.facebook.com/1500196238/posts/10222594365076738/?flite=scwspnss&mibextid=8zPu1hDEvIDGMfmn

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Helen Mirren once said: Before you argue with someone, ask yourself.......

Helen Mirren once said: Before you argue with someone, ask yourself, is that person even mentally mature enough to grasp the concept of a different perspective. Because if not, there's absolutely no point. Not every argument is worth your energy. Sometimes, no matter how clearly you express yourself, the other person isn’t listening to understand—they’re listening to react. They’re stuck in their own perspective, unwilling to consider another viewpoint, and engaging with them only drains you. There’s a difference between a healthy discussion and a pointless debate. A conversation with someone who is open-minded, who values growth and understanding, can be enlightening—even if you don’t agree. But trying to reason with someone who refuses to see beyond their own beliefs? That’s like talking to a wall. No matter how much logic or truth you present, they will twist, deflect, or dismiss your words, not because you’re wrong, but because they’re unwilling to see another side. Maturity is...
Post a Comment
Read more

Why BJP is opposing the Telangana caste census?

The BJP opposes the Telangana caste census primarily due to concerns about its political motivations, alleging that the Congress party is using it for electoral gain rather than genuine welfare of Backward Classes (BCs)  1 3 .  BJP leaders argue that the census distracts from Congress's unfulfilled promises to BCs and could exacerbate social divisions  2 4 .  Additionally, there are fears within the BJP that a detailed caste enumeration might reveal ongoing upper-caste dominance in politics and society, which could challenge their support base  7 8 . The BJP's main arguments against the caste census include: Political Manipulation : BJP leaders assert that the Congress party is using the caste census for political advantage rather than for the welfare of Backward Classes (BCs), claiming it distracts from unfulfilled promises made to these communities  2 4 . Threat to Hindutva Agenda : The party views the census as a potential challenge to its support base a...
Post a Comment
Read more

JAI HIND: WHO DO WE OWE IT TO?

Though the origin of Jai Hind is usually ascribed to Chempakaraman  Pillai in 1907, it didn’t have a popular usage till Netaji Bose made it the standard greeting of the INA. How this happened to be has a Hyderabad connection. It is believed by Netaji’s close followers that the slogan "Jai Hind" as coined by Abid Hasan Safrani.   Abid Hasan Safrani  was the son of the soil of Hyderabad in India. His real name was Zainul Abedin Hasan. He preferred to be called Abid Hasan. His parents expired during the British Raj. Before that they had sent him to Germany instead of England for higher studies in Engineering stream. During the that time, Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose visited Germany and addressed Indian  prisoners of war & also students and asked them  to join Indian National Army (Azad Hind Fauj). Abid Hasan met him and got inspired by the charisma of Netaji.  He told him that he would join him after finishing his studies. Netaji said tautingly t...
Post a Comment
Read more